Lefebvrist Bishop says No Reconciliation with Rome- 091505

Home
Gregorian Masses
About Site Originator
Site Purpose
SSPX Overview
AGENDA - Section 1
AGENDA - Section 6
AGENDA - Section 8
AGENDA - Section 10
Canonical History of SSPX
Ecclesia Dei - Apostolic Letter of John Paul II
Matrimony
Penance
Sunday Obligation
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Cardinal Lara and the Vanishing Schism
FIDELITY ARTICLE - The Vanishing Schism Revisited: Will the Real Cardinal Lara Stand Up (Again)?
FIDELITY ARTICLE - In the Line of Fire: Fr. John Rizzo, Ex-SSPX
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Letters to the Editor, December 1992
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Letters to the Editor, February 1993
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Marcel Lefebvre: Signatory to Dignitatis Humanae
FIDELITY ARTICLE - No Ordinary Bishop
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Schism, Obedience and the Society of St. Pius X
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Schism of Lefebvre: Review of Nemeth's The Case of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre
FIDELITY ARTICLE - Society of St. Pius X Gets Sick (the article that started it all)
MISC. ARTICLES - Archbishop Lefebvre and Canons 1323:4° and 1324 §1:5
MISC. ARTICLES - Can. 844 §2 -- Can a Catholic Approach an SSPX Priest for the Sacraments?
MISC. ARTICLES - Candid Admissions of Bishop Tissier de Mallerais
MISC. ARTICLES - Consecration of Bishops and Papal Authority
MISC. ARTICLES - Custom and the 1962 Roman Missal
MISC. ARTICLES - Declaration by Pontifical Council for the Interpretation of Legislative Texts
MISC. ARTICLES - Ecclesia Dei: Apostolic Letter of John Paul II
MISC. ARTICLES - Decree of Excommunication
MISC. ARTICLES - Excommunication of Followers of Archbishop Lefebvre
MISC. ARTICLES - Howard Walsh
MISC. ARTICLES - Introduction to the Lefebvrist Schism
MISC. ARTICLES - Letter to Cardinal Ratzinger (consequences of patronizing the SSPX)
MISC. ARTICLES - Letter of Msgr. Perl
MISC. ARTICLES - Nebraska Excommunications Allowed to Stand
MISC. ARTICLES - Ottaviani Repudiates "Intervention"
MISC. ARTICLES - Protocol
MISC. ARTICLES - SSPX in Australia
MISC. ARTICLES -SSPX Vis-A-Vis Vatican I
MISC. ARTICLES - Traditionalism: True & False
MISC. ARTICLES - Was the Tridentine Mass Banned by Pope Paul VI?
Lefebvrist Bishop says No Reconciliation with Rome- 091505
Vatican Official Sees Broader Use of Latin Mass - 092605
Interview with Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos, President of Ecclesia Dei - 083105
A Break In The Logjam? - 012306
Pope, Curia to Discuss SSPX Reconciliation - 020306
No Compromise with Vatican says SSPX Leader - 020706
Pope, Curia to Hold Talks on SSPX and Reforms - 031706
Talks Continue Between Vatican, SSPX - 092206
Vatican Official - Pope to Loosen Restrictions on Use of Old Latin Mass - 101106
Pope will Broaden Use of Latin Mass - 101106
Pro-Multis means "For Many," Vatican Rules - 111806
Limit Role of Extraordinary Ministers, Vatican Tells US - 102606
In France, Cardinal Arinze Decries Liturgical Abuses - 102706
Vatican Affirms US Bishop's Excommunication of Lay Group - 121106
Personal Parish for French Latin Mass Catholics
Archbishop Ranjith: the Holy Father Must Decide - 022307
Cardinal Confirms Plans to Revive Latin Mass - 052107
Pope Scraps 40 Year Restriction on Latin Mass - 070707
Schismatic Nuns Return to the Church - 070907
Scott Letter, 29 November, 1992
Msgr. Calkins on the Mass, the Council and Traditionalists
Fatima Conspiracy Theories Crumble - Sr. Lucy Speaks
Use of the Tridentine Mass without Indult
Custom and the 1962 Missal
Schismatic Groups Coming Home, Vatican Reports - 011308
Vatican Official: Church Should Reconsider Communion in the Hand - 013108
Map location of Mel Gibson's church
Pope to Cancel Excommunications of Rebel Bishops
Bishop Fellay's Letter to Swedish Television Station
Rome has Lifted Excommunicatons
Article says SSPX Still In Schism
Vatican-Pius X Society Talks Set for October
Williamson Ousted

Catholic World News

Lefebvrist bishop says no reconciliation with Rome

http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=39641

September 15, 2005 (CWNews.com) — A bishop of the schismatic Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) has warned traditionalist Catholics the "heresy of neo-modernism" which, he says, now controls the Vatican.

williamson_bishop_richard.jpg

In an email message to his supporters, Bishop Richard Williamson, an English-born prelate who now serves the SSPX in Argentina, said that there are enormous differences "between Catholic Tradition and the position's of today's Rome."  He continued: "Between these positions, any reconciliation is impossible."

Bishop Williamson conceded that some traditionalists might accept an offer of reconciliation with the Vatican, but "the conciliar positions of today's Rome would still be as false as 2 and 2 are 5, while the Traditional positions would still be as true as 2 and 2 are 4."

The Lefebvrist bishop wrote his email message to explain why he had said -- prior to the September 1 meeting between Pope Benedict XVI and Bishop Bernard Fellay, the head of the SSPX -- that traditionalists would not be reconciled with the Vatican.  He explained that if some traditionalists were to reach an agreement with the Vatican, others would resist -- "that if the Society [of St. Pius X] were to rejoin Rome, the resistance of Catholic Tradition would carry on without it."

Bishop Williamson, the most outspoken figure in the SSPX, is one of the four bishops consecrated by the late Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in June 1988, in defiance of an order from the Vatican, prompting Pope John Paul II to announce the excommunication of the traditionalist leaders.